Standard Interpretation
Standard: 2003 NELAC
Section: Appendix D.1.1.2.1
Link to relevant standard
REQUEST:
Can control limits include 0? Marginal exceedances must be random. If control limits don't include 0, poor performing analytes will consistently be marginal exceedances.
Same question for demonstration of capability.
TNI FINAL RESPONSE:
(Quality Systems Expert Committee/NELAP Board, 10-25-08)
The laboratory would have to demonstrate how its data can meet all other aspects of the method and still generate control limits that include a 0% recovery. However, there is no restriction on control limits using 0 - look at PT criteria for soil to see examples of this occurring.
As for marginal exceedances, there's no such thing as a "consistent marginal exceedance", since they are required to be random. Consistent means that there is something wrong in the process or the method just doesn’t work for that analyte.

develop consensus standards for use by TNI's programs. This group has a support role in assisting other programs with activities such as guidance and standards interpretation.
fosters the generation of data of known and documented quality is through the National Environmental Laboratory Accreditation Program, or NELAP. The purpose of this program is to establish and implement a program for the accreditation of environmental laboratories.
is to establish and maintain a national PT program to support TNI’s National Environmental Laboratory Accreditation Program, and other activities.
Field Activities Program (NEFAP) Executive Committee is to establish and implement an accreditation program for field sampling and measurement organizations (FSMOs).
Audit Sample Program is to develop consensus standards for the manufacture and analysis of audit samples for source emission testing.
on a variety of topics of interest to the environmental measurement community. TNI also hosts two regularly scheduled meetings per year, typically in January and August. Both are a week long and involve open meetings of TNI committees as well as training courses and other special sessions.